West Papua: The Pacific’s new test of Indonesia’s sovereignty narrative
Ali Mirin, a West Papuan academic and writer from the Kimyal people, argues that the 55th Pacific Islands Forum Leaders’ Meeting in Koror, Palau, brought West Papua back to the centre of Pacific diplomacy, and that Indonesia’s claim to sovereignty cannot close the discussion. Recognised sovereignty, he writes, does not cancel a state’s human rights obligations or prevent international bodies from seeking access.
Mirin describes how Melanesian Spearhead Group leaders, meeting on the margins of the Forum, renewed their call for the UN human rights office to visit the West Papuan provinces before 31 December 2026, when Indonesia’s presidency of the UN Human Rights Council ends. They said Indonesia’s associate membership of the MSG would be reviewed at the 2027 summit if the visit did not happen. He revisits the 1962 New York Agreement and the 1969 “Act of Free Choice”, in which 1,026 selected representatives endorsed integration, and argues that the real question is whether that process was a free expression of the people’s will. He also points to the gap between Indonesia’s anti-colonial statements at the UN and its position on Papua.
Mirin concludes that the Pacific has not endorsed independence, but that the language of the debate is moving from a choice between Indonesia and independence toward sovereignty with accountability. He sets out what a credible UN visit would need, including freedom of movement, private meetings with Indigenous communities, access to conflict and displacement areas and publication of the findings, and warns that dialogue without deadlines becomes a holding pattern.
Full article
Read the full article on Asia Pacific Report
Support our work
Support our work
Support our work with a one-off or monthly donation

