Report · Palestine
Meta’s Broken Promises
Systemic Censorship of Palestine Content on Instagram and Facebook
by Human Rights Watch · 2023
About the report
Between October and November 2023 Human Rights Watch reviewed more than 1,050 cases of content removed or suppressed on Instagram and Facebook. All but one involved peaceful content in support of Palestine, posted by people in over 60 countries. The organisation concludes that Meta’s censorship of Palestine content is systemic and global, and that the company has broken years of promises to fix it.
The report identifies six recurring patterns, each seen at least 100 times: removal of posts, stories and comments; suspension or disabling of accounts; bans on liking, commenting or sharing; restrictions on following or tagging; loss of features such as Live; and “shadow banning”. Even comments sharing Human Rights Watch’s own call for evidence were taken down. Illustrative cases include the Palestinian flag emoji, the phrase “from the river to the sea” and criticism of Israel treated as hate speech.
Four underlying causes are traced: Meta’s sweeping Dangerous Organizations and Individuals policy, which leans on US terrorist lists; inconsistent use of its newsworthiness allowance; opaque handling of government takedown requests, including from Israel’s Cyber Unit; and heavy reliance on automated moderation. The report builds on years of work by 7amleh and Access Now and ends with detailed recommendations to Meta on policy, transparency, appeals and human rights due diligence.
Read the report? Take the next step.
Join a Palestine solidarity group near you, travel with a delegation to Palestine, or become part of Solidarity Rising.
More reports on Palestine
Share via
Related resources
Seize the Moral Low Ground: Land Seizure for “Security Needs” in the West Bank
Kerem Navot shows how Israel used military seizure orders for 'security needs'…
Two Authorities, One Way, Zero Dissent: Arbitrary Arrest and Torture Under the Palestinian Authority and Hamas
Human Rights Watch documents how the PA and Hamas arrest Palestinians for…
Bed and Breakfast on Stolen Land: Tourist Rental Listings in West Bank Settlements
Human Rights Watch and Kerem Navot show how Airbnb and Booking.com profit from…






