Whose Consent?: On the Joined Cases C-779/21 P, Commission v Front Polisario and C-799/21 P, Council v Front Polisario
Jed Odermatt analyses the judgment of 4 October 2024 in which the Grand Chamber of the Court of Justice of the European Union upheld the annulment of two EU-Morocco agreements, on trade and fisheries, as far as they applied to Western Sahara. It was the first time the Court annulled an EU agreement for breaching international law binding on the Union. Odermatt recalls the earlier rulings, which held that Western Sahara is separate and distinct from Morocco and that agreements can only apply there with the consent of its people, and the consultations the Commission held with groups in the territory, which Front Polisario rejected.
The commentary explains three issues. On standing, the Court found that Front Polisario can challenge EU acts because UN resolutions treat it as a privileged interlocutor representing the people of Western Sahara. On the standard of review, it rejected the argument that EU institutions have wide discretion in applying international law. On consent, it upheld the finding that the people of Western Sahara did not consent, while setting out a new test of implied consent based on “specific, tangible, substantial and verifiable” benefits. Odermatt also notes that Advocate General Ćapeta had treated Morocco as an administering power able to consent, a view criticised for ignoring UN practice.
Odermatt concludes that the judgment is a landmark in the Court’s use of international law, and that it may matter for EU dealings with other disputed territories, including Israel’s settlements after the ICJ’s 2024 advisory opinion. He also points out that the Court delayed the annulment by 12 months and left room for new agreements, so its approach still allows Morocco’s occupation of Western Sahara to continue.
Full article
Read the full commentary on Verfassungsblog
Support our work
Support our work
Support our work with a one-off or monthly donation
Share via
Related resources
Western Sahara: Stalemate and Its Discontents, Alice Wilson
Anthropologist Alice Wilson, then at the University of Cambridge, speaks at the…
Western Sahara: Time to Be Free, Public Meeting in Dublin
Mohamed Belsat, the Polisario Front's representative to Europe, Sahrawi human…
The Ideal Refugees: Gender, Islam and the Sahrawi Politics of Survival, Elena Fiddian-Qasmiyeh
Elena Fiddian-Qasmiyeh of University College London presents her book The Ideal…



