Animal Welfare and Hierarchies of Suffering in Gaza
Asmaa Abu Mezied starts from German media reports in November 2025 about four donkeys taken from Gaza by an Israeli sanctuary and moved to a German zoo, coverage that said nothing about children denied evacuation or the ongoing genocide. She calls this a “theater of care”: a performance of humanitarian concern shaped by racial hierarchies of whose suffering counts. Animals are treated as innocent and outside politics, while Palestinians are treated as political and therefore less worthy of grief.
She gives examples, including campaigns that called Gaza’s Khan Younis Zoo “the world’s worst zoo” while giving little attention to the blockade and bombing, and the story of Hamed Ashour, whose dog stayed with him in his tent. After his post went viral, an Irish animal welfare group contacted him about evacuating the dog, without asking about his own safety. Abu Mezied argues that rescuing animals asks nothing of the occupying power and requires no reckoning with the siege.
The commentary also shows how animal removal harms Palestinian survival. During the genocide, donkeys have carried the wounded, water and food when ambulances were bombed. Abu Mezied places their removal within a longer history of Israeli attacks on Palestinian herding and livestock, including grazing land declared closed military zones after 1967. She concludes that this form of humanitarianism lets Western actors feel compassion while leaving colonial structures in place, and asks why care for animals becomes actionable while care for Palestinian lives is deferred or denied.
Full article
Read the full commentary on Al-Shabaka
Support our work
Support our work
Support our work with a one-off or monthly donation
Share via
Related resources
Western Sahara: Stalemate and Its Discontents, Alice Wilson
Anthropologist Alice Wilson, then at the University of Cambridge, speaks at the…
Western Sahara: Time to Be Free, Public Meeting in Dublin
Mohamed Belsat, the Polisario Front's representative to Europe, Sahrawi human…
The Ideal Refugees: Gender, Islam and the Sahrawi Politics of Survival, Elena Fiddian-Qasmiyeh
Elena Fiddian-Qasmiyeh of University College London presents her book The Ideal…



