Report · Palestine
Challenging the Israeli Attorney General’s Conception of Sovereignty
The issue of jurisdiction concerning the ‘Situation of Palestine’ before the International Criminal Court
by Adalah · 2020
About the report
In this report, Adalah, The Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel, responds to the Israeli Attorney General’s memorandum of 20 December 2019, which opposed the International Criminal Court’s exercise of jurisdiction over the situation in Palestine. Adalah argues that the memorandum rests on an outdated and formalistic idea of state sovereignty, and that it contradicts positions the Attorney General has himself taken before the Israeli Supreme Court, as well as that court’s own case law.
The report points out that the memorandum says nothing about the Palestinian population and makes no attempt to answer the Prosecutor’s arguments about prima facie war crimes committed by Israel against Palestinians. Adalah argues that international human rights law follows a functional approach, which looks at how a state exercises power over the people under its effective control, and that the main goal of international legal practice today is the defence of victims.
Adalah explains that Article 12(3) of the Rome Statute should be read so that the term “State” includes a quasi-State that is a party to the Statute, enjoys a recognised international status and faces matters of impunity. It concludes that the interests of victims and of justice require the ICC to exercise jurisdiction, and that the main cases of impunity concern the Gaza Strip, whose closure and legal status the second part of the report examines.
Read the report? Take the next step.
Join a Palestine solidarity group near you, travel with a delegation to Palestine, or become part of Solidarity Rising.
Related resources
West Papua: The Pacific’s new test of Indonesia’s sovereignty narrative
Ali Mirin argues that Indonesia's sovereignty claim cannot end Pacific scrutiny…

