Report · Palestine
A Critical Analysis of the Biased Review of UNRWA’s Neutrality
BADIL position paper on the Independent Review of UNRWA
by BADIL Resource Center for Palestinian Residency and Refugee Rights · 2024
About the report
In early 2024 Israel accused 12 of UNRWA’s roughly 13,000 staff in Gaza of taking part in the events of 7 October, and several donors froze funding. On 5 February the UN Secretary-General appointed an Independent Review Group to assess the agency’s neutrality. This BADIL position paper analyses the Review’s final report and the risks it poses to UNRWA and to Palestine refugees.
BADIL notes that the Review itself praised UNRWA’s neutrality frameworks as unusually robust, yet went on to make recommendations that, the paper argues, have little to do with neutrality and are politically driven. It identifies eight strategic risks, among them defining neutrality through Israel’s definition of terrorism, creating outside supervisory structures, “internationalising” the agency and its staff, giving Israel a direct say over UNRWA’s work, transferring parts of its mandate under the label of partnership, securitising the agency, pressing it to strip Palestinian content from school curricula, and ignoring the protection owed to Palestinian staff and refugees.
The paper closes with recommendations aimed at preserving UNRWA’s mandate until refugees can exercise their right of return. It is a valuable resource for understanding the wider campaign against UNRWA and why refugee rights advocates see the agency’s survival as a political question, not only a humanitarian one.
Read the report? Take the next step.
Join a Palestine solidarity group near you, travel with a delegation to Palestine, or become part of Solidarity Rising.
More reports on Palestine
Related resources
Seize the Moral Low Ground: Land Seizure for “Security Needs” in the West Bank
Kerem Navot shows how Israel used military seizure orders for 'security needs'…
Two Authorities, One Way, Zero Dissent: Arbitrary Arrest and Torture Under the Palestinian Authority and Hamas
Human Rights Watch documents how the PA and Hamas arrest Palestinians for…
Bed and Breakfast on Stolen Land: Tourist Rental Listings in West Bank Settlements
Human Rights Watch and Kerem Navot show how Airbnb and Booking.com profit from…






