Report · Palestine
The Gaps and Failures of the ICJ’s 2024 Advisory Opinion on Palestine
A critical analysis of the Advisory Opinion on the legal consequences of Israel’s policies and practices in the occupied Palestinian territory
by BADIL Resource Center for Palestinian Residency and Refugee Rights · 2024
About the report
On 19 July 2024 the International Court of Justice found Israel’s policies and practices in the occupied Palestinian territory unlawful, including as a breach of the prohibition of racial segregation and apartheid in Article 3 of CERD, and reaffirmed the Palestinian right to self-determination. BADIL welcomes those findings but argues in this position paper that the opinion also contains serious gaps.
The central criticism is decontextualisation. Because the Court confined itself to the territory occupied in 1967, BADIL argues, it left aside the root causes of the colonisation of Palestine, gave an insufficient account of the present situation, and as a result read the rights to self-determination, return and resistance too narrowly. The paper also contends that the Court stepped beyond its advisory role by endorsing political outcomes such as the two-state framework.
A final section traces how these weaknesses carried over into the UN General Assembly resolution of 18 September 2024 that gave effect to the opinion. The paper is a useful counterpoint for anyone using the Advisory Opinion in advocacy: it shows what the ruling gives the Palestinian cause and where, in BADIL’s view, it falls short of the rights of the Palestinian people as a whole, refugees included.
Read the report? Take the next step.
Join a Palestine solidarity group near you, travel with a delegation to Palestine, or become part of Solidarity Rising.
More reports on Palestine
Related resources
Seize the Moral Low Ground: Land Seizure for “Security Needs” in the West Bank
Kerem Navot shows how Israel used military seizure orders for 'security needs'…
Two Authorities, One Way, Zero Dissent: Arbitrary Arrest and Torture Under the Palestinian Authority and Hamas
Human Rights Watch documents how the PA and Hamas arrest Palestinians for…
Bed and Breakfast on Stolen Land: Tourist Rental Listings in West Bank Settlements
Human Rights Watch and Kerem Navot show how Airbnb and Booking.com profit from…






